How to Find a Portland Buyer’s Agent Who Actually Knows What They’re Doing

Ok, so maybe the headline is a bit harsh. Still, last year in the Portland metro over 8500 real estate agents recorded at least one sale. There are going to be great ones, there are going to be serviceable ones, and there are going to be…the rest. If you’re new to buying or it’s just been a while, how in this highly online world we live in do you find the best fit?

Searching for a buyer’s agent will lead you down a few common paths. Let’s take them one at a time:

Referral
Over 50% of a successful real estate agent’s transactions come from repeat business or referrals. Those are the calls us Realtors love the most, since it means someone has trusted us enough to either hire us again or recommend us to friends or family. If you have friends or family who have recently been in a real estate transaction, ask them what they thought about their Realtor. Really ask, and if the answer is “uh, fine, I guess” I’d go collect some more suggestions.

Open Houses
Open houses serve two purposes: gain exposure for the home being sold, and gain exposure for the agent holding it open. Often, that agent is not the listing agent for the home. It may be the industry’s worst-kept-secret that if an agent other than the listing agent is hosting the open house, the primary goal is to meet new buyer clients.

That’s a way of saying that visiting open houses and talking to the agents hosting them will teach you a great deal about that person, since they’re auditioning for the job just by being there. Consider it a pre-interview. Is the agent knowledgeable about the house? The neighborhood? The local market? Economic trends? How did they prepare for this open house? Are they cleaned up and dressed decently? Are they trying to really help you, or just get your contact info? Do you LIKE this person who, if you hire, you’ll be spending a lot of time with?

Ask questions. A lot of them. Here are some questions they should know the answer to off the top of their head, if they prepared:

– How old are the roof, HVAC, and water heater?
– Which three public schools is the address zoned for?
– How much are the most recent property taxes?
– If there’s an HOA, how much are the dues and what do you get for them?
– Where’s the nearest supermarket?

If they can answer those questions (or at least give a real reason for why they don’t know, often sellers don’t even know how old the roof is), you’ll know that they didn’t just roll up to the open house five minutes before it started without doing any homework first.

Just Google/ChatGPT/etc. it!
I did an experiment–I opened a private browser, went to ChatGPT, and asked it to recommend five great buyer agents in Beaverton. I’m someone who does this full time, I follow the local market very closely and know the players, and I only recognized one name on the list. Also, none of the photos that ChatGPT displayed matched the people, which is actually kind of funny. I then looked myself up and found that I’m now twenty years younger and have much more hair. Thank you, ChatGPT!

What it is focused on are the quantity of Google reviews. The five Realtors it picked each have a high, if not abnormal, if not suspect, amount of reviews. None of them had any particularly notable connection to Beaverton except that their offices were in Beaverton (which really doesn’t matter, who goes to the office these days anyway).

They’re certainly all very good at getting people to review them, and making sure those reviews are funneled to Google rather than other sites. For example, one of the five has 90 Google reviews but only four Zillow reviews. It’s worth noting that Zillow requires that reviewers were involved in a transaction with the Realtor–no peer-to-peer reviews allowed.

Incidentally, I was in a training class recently where it was suggested that us Realtors reach out to everyone involved in a transaction (other Realtor, lender, title company, home inspector, etc.) and basically trade Google reviews to goose the count. That’s too dodgy for me, but I have no doubt that others are doing it.

Google’s Gemini wasn’t much better. I recognized all five of their recommendations, but of them:

– Two were team leaders of large teams that are primarily focused on listings, not buyers
– Gemini changed one’s last name to something slightly different
– Following each of the five external links led to the same Realtor’s site

I tend to think that AI is fine for vetting your choices, but pretty bad at actually recommending them. No matter how confident it sounds, the accuracy is still suspect.

The struggle it has is recommending agents who do great work rather than agents who are just great at lead generation. That’s an agent who is just trying to get to closing to move on to the next one. It will also be biased to high-producing agents and large teams, who probably aren’t the best fit for a buyer (and definitely aren’t for a first-time buyer). They tend to focus on getting listings, and after the initial meeting with the name-on-the-door you might end up spending all of your time with someone on their team who handles the buyers.

Social Media
A Realtor providing useful and focused information might be worth looking up. They’re trying.
A Realtor showing off their sweet dance moves on TikTok, not so much.


When you find someone, they’ll want to sit down for a proper buyer consultation with you to discuss your goals in detail and what strategies to employ. Bring your questions. Among the most important things to find out:

– How well do they explain complex ideas, and do they do it patiently?

– Things move very fast once you’re actively shopping. How quickly can you expect replies
to your calls, texts, or emails? There’s nothing worse than waiting around for answers
when time is of the essence.

– Are they full time? Yes, many Realtors try and do this as a side hustle, and won’t be
volunteering that information. You need someone with maximum availability, not a
dentist (for real, I encountered one) selling real estate on the side.

– Do they have a grasp on current market conditions? Can they back it up with data,
or are they talking out of their you-know-what?

– Vibe check: are you getting along? This matters. You don’t need to be buddies (and
probably shouldn’t), but you will be spending a lot of time together.

One final note. Experience definitely matters, but it’s not everything. In every profession or hobby there are people who have been at it for a long time but stopped learning a long time ago. Real estate is changing constantly and quickly, and you need someone who has been keeping up with it. One of the most cringe sayings I hear (in any endeavor, not just real estate) is “I’ve been doing this for X years, so…”

So why are you so bad at it?